Judges 6:13

My Notes

What Does Judges 6:13 Mean?

Gideon responds to the angel's greeting ("The LORD is with thee, thou mighty man of valour") with the most honest objection in Judges: "Oh my Lord, if the LORD be with us, why then is all this befallen us? and where be all his miracles?" The question is raw, personal, and theologically loaded: if God is with us, why is everything falling apart? Where are the miracles our fathers told us about? The Exodus stories don't match the Midianite reality.

Gideon's question contains a pain that every generation of believers carries: the gap between the God of the stories and the God of the present. The fathers told amazing stories—Red Sea, manna, fire on Sinai. But the present reality is Midianite oppression, hiding in winepresses, and a nation reduced to poverty. The stories say God is powerful. The experience says God is absent. The tension between inherited theology and present experience is Gideon's crisis.

The angel doesn't answer the question. He commissions Gideon instead (verse 14: "Go in this thy might, and thou shalt save Israel from the hand of the Midianites"). The answer to "where are the miracles?" is: you. You are the miracle God is sending. The deliverance you're waiting for is the deliverance God is sending you to produce. The miracle isn't coming from the sky. It's being commissioned in a winepress.

Reflection Questions

• 1.Have you asked Gideon's question—if God is with us, why is everything falling apart?
• 2.The gap between inherited stories and present experience: which is louder in your life—the testimony or the suffering?
• 3.God's answer wasn't explanation but commission: you are the miracle. What if your question is answered by your calling?
• 4.Gideon was hiding in a winepress when God called him 'mighty man of valour.' What is God calling you that doesn't match your current circumstances?

Devotional

"If the LORD be with us, why then is all this befallen us?" Gideon asks the question every honest believer eventually asks: if God is real and God is here, why is everything falling apart? Where are the miracles the old people talk about? The stories say God parts seas. My experience says Midianites take everything.

The gap between the God of the stories and the God of the present is Gideon's crisis—and yours. Your parents or grandparents told you about answered prayers, miraculous provision, dramatic deliverance. You heard the testimonies. You memorized the stories. And now you're hiding in a winepress because the enemy has reduced your life to subsistence. The stories say one thing. Your life says another. And the tension between the two produces Gideon's question: if God is with us, where is He?

The angel doesn't answer. He commissions. The response to "where are the miracles?" isn't an explanation. It's an assignment: go. In this thy might. Save Israel. You want miracles? You're the miracle. The deliverance you've been waiting for God to send from heaven is the deliverance God is sending through you, from the winepress. The answer to your theological question is a practical commission: stop waiting for the miracle and go be it.

Gideon's question is honest and the honesty is honored—not with a theological lecture but with a calling. God doesn't rebuke the question. He redirects it. You asked where the miracles are. I'm looking at one. You asked why God hasn't acted. I'm commissioning you to be the action. The miracle you're waiting for is hiding in the same winepress you are. It's you.

Commentary

Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.

Cross References

Related passages throughout Scripture