“And a man's uncle shall take him up, and he that burneth him, to bring out the bones out of the house, and shall say unto him that is by the sides of the house, Is there yet any with thee? and he shall say, No. Then shall he say, Hold thy tongue: for we may not make mention of the name of the LORD.”
My Notes
What Does Amos 6:10 Mean?
"And a man's uncle shall take him up, and he that burneth him, to bring out the bones out of the house, and shall say unto him that is by the sides of the house, Is there yet any with thee? and he shall say, No. Then shall he say, Hold thy tongue: for we may not make mention of the name of the LORD." The scene is a house of the dead: an uncle comes to collect the bodies and a burner comes to cremate the remains. They ask: is ANYONE ELSE alive in there? The answer: No. And then the shocking instruction: be QUIET. Don't mention the LORD's name. The fear is so great that even invoking God's name in grief is dangerous — the mention itself might attract MORE divine attention. MORE judgment.
The phrase "hold thy tongue" (has — hush, be silent) commands SILENCE about God: the survivors are so terrified of divine judgment that they won't even SAY God's name. The silence isn't reverence. It's TERROR. The survivors believe that mentioning God's name will draw His attention — and His attention is the last thing they want. The God whose name should bring comfort brings dread.
The "we may not make mention of the name of the LORD" (ki lo lehazkhir beshem YHWH — for it is not to be mentioned in the name of the LORD) treats God's name as DANGEROUS: saying it might invoke it. Invoking it might attract judgment. The name that should be praised in grief is instead hushed in terror. The theology has been inverted — God's name is a threat, not a comfort.
Reflection Questions
- 1.Have you ever been afraid to invoke God's name — afraid that His attention might make things worse?
- 2.What does fear converting God's name from comfort to threat teach about corrupted theology?
- 3.How does the uncle collecting bodies describe the domestic scale of divine judgment?
- 4.What does grieving in SILENCE (afraid to mention God) look like in your experience?
Devotional
An uncle collecting bodies. A burner cremating remains. 'Is anyone alive in there?' 'No.' 'Then be QUIET. Don't say God's name.' The fear is so total that even mentioning the LORD might bring MORE judgment. The survivors aren't praying. They're HIDING — from a God whose attention terrifies them.
The scene is domestic horror: the plague or judgment has killed so many that an uncle must collect the bodies from a house. The burner disposes of the remains. The question 'is there yet any with thee?' is asked from OUTSIDE — the questioner doesn't want to enter the house of death. And the answer is the loneliest word: No. Nobody else. Just the dead and me.
The 'hold thy tongue, for we may not make mention of the name of the LORD' is the theology of terror: God's name isn't invoked in grief. It's SUPPRESSED. The survivors believe that saying 'the LORD' might attract MORE divine attention — and divine attention is what produced the bodies they're collecting. The name that should comfort mourners terrifies survivors. The God who should be called upon in crisis is the God they're hiding from.
The inversion is the tragedy: in healthy faith, God's name is spoken in grief for comfort ('the LORD gives and the LORD takes away' — Job 1:21). In this scene, God's name is HUSHED in grief for self-preservation. The name isn't comfort. It's threat. The mention isn't prayer. It's danger. The theology has been so corrupted by judgment that the survivors can't even grieve properly — they grieve in silence because God's name is too frightening to say.
Have you ever been so afraid of God that you were afraid to say His name — even in your grief?
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
And a man's uncle shall take him up,.... That is, his father's brother, as Kimchi; or his near kinsman, as the Targum;…
And a man’s uncle ... and he that burneth him - Literally, “and there shall take him up his uncle and his burner,” that…
A man's uncle shall take him up - Bp. Newcome says, this obscure verse seems to describe the effects of famine and…
In the former part of the chapter we had these secure Israelites loading themselves with pleasures, as if they could…
A grim episode imagined by the prophet (cf. Isa 3:6 f.) for the purpose of illustrating vividly the terrors of the time:…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture