“They have set up kings, but not by me: they have made princes, and I knew it not: of their silver and their gold have they made them idols, that they may be cut off.”
My Notes
What Does Hosea 8:4 Mean?
"They have set up kings, but not by me: they have made princes, and I knew it not: of their silver and their gold have they made them idols, that they may be cut off." God catalogs three acts of autonomy — and each one excludes Him more completely than the last.
"Set up kings, but not by me" — Israel chose their own political leadership without consulting God. The northern kingdom's history was a series of dynasties established through assassination and coup — Jeroboam, Baasha, Omri, Jehu — most of them without divine sanction. They installed rulers based on military strength and political maneuvering, not prophetic anointing. God says: you did this without Me.
"Made princes, and I knew it not" — "I knew it not" (lo yadati) doesn't mean God was unaware. It means He wasn't consulted. He wasn't part of the decision. It's relational language, not cognitive: you didn't include Me. The princes — the administrative structure, the power brokers — were appointed in a process that treated God as irrelevant.
"Of their silver and their gold have they made them idols" — the wealth God gave them (2:8) was melted down and reshaped into the gods they worshipped instead of Him. God's gifts became God's competitors. The silver and gold — which came from God's provision — were converted into the images that replaced Him.
"That they may be cut off" — the purpose clause is devastating. The result of all this autonomy — the self-appointed kings, the unauthorized princes, the self-made idols — is destruction. Not flourishing. Cutting off. Everything they built without God leads to their own elimination.
Reflection Questions
- 1.What major decisions have you made recently 'without consulting' God — where He wasn't part of the process?
- 2.Israel used God's gifts to make idols. What resources God has given you (time, money, talent) have you invested in things that compete with Him?
- 3.The progression goes: decisions without God → structures without God → gods without God. Where are you on that progression?
- 4.Everything built without God leads to being 'cut off.' Is there something in your life you've built autonomously that you can feel crumbling?
Devotional
Three decisions, each one made without God. A government chosen without Him. Leaders installed without consulting Him. His own gifts melted into idols. The progression is a masterclass in how autonomy from God works: you start by making decisions without Him, and you end by making gods without Him.
The sequence matters. It starts with political leadership — choosing who's in charge based on human criteria without asking God. Then it moves to administrative structure — building systems and appointing people without divine input. Then it reaches its logical conclusion: the resources God provided are used to construct the gods that replace Him. Each step is further from God than the last. And each step feels rational in the moment.
You might not be setting up kings. But the pattern translates perfectly. Making career decisions without consulting God. Building relational structures without His input. Taking the resources He's given you — time, money, talent, influence — and investing them in things that compete with Him for your devotion. Silver and gold made into idols.
The final phrase is the one that should haunt you: "that they may be cut off." Everything built in autonomy from God leads to being cut off. Not because God is vindictive. Because structures built without the foundation eventually collapse. Kings without God's backing are overthrown. Princes without God's anointing are swept away. Idols made from God's gifts consume the people who made them.
The alternative is simpler than you think: include Him. In the decision. In the structure. In the use of the resources. God says "not by me" and "I knew it not" — the complaint isn't complexity. It's exclusion.
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
They have set up kings, but not by me,.... Not by his authority, order, and command; not by asking advice of him, or his…
They have set up kings, but not by ME - God Himself foretold to Jeroboam by Ahijah the prophet, that He would “rend the…
They have set up kings, but not by me - Properly speaking, not one of the kings of Israel, from the defection of the ten…
The reproofs and threatenings here are introduced with an order to the prophet to set the trumpet to his mouth (Hos…
Israel's great offence making a schism in the -theocratic" community. Setting up idols was virtually rebellion against…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture