“He answereth and saith unto them, He that hath two coats, let him impart to him that hath none; and he that hath meat, let him do likewise.”
My Notes
What Does Luke 3:11 Mean?
"He answereth and saith unto them, He that hath two coats, let him impart to him that hath none; and he that hath meat, let him do likewise." John the Baptist's answer to 'what shall we do?' (verse 10) is stunningly PRACTICAL: if you have two coats, give one away. If you have food, share it. The repentance John preaches doesn't produce abstract spiritual exercises. It produces CONCRETE MATERIAL GENEROSITY. The fruit of repentance is a coat handed to a cold person. The evidence of turned hearts is shared food.
The phrase "he that hath two coats, let him impart" (ho echōn duo chitōnas metadotō tō mē echonti — the one having two tunics let him give to the one not having) establishes the SIMPLEST possible standard of generosity: you don't need wealth to practice it. You need TWO of something when someone else has NONE. The standard isn't sacrificial giving from luxury. It's SHARING from sufficiency. You have two. Someone has zero. The math is obvious. The action is immediate.
The "he that hath meat, let him do likewise" (kai ho echōn brōmata homoiōs poieitō — and the one having food in the same way let him do) extends the principle to FOOD: the same standard applies. If you have food and someone doesn't, share. The generosity isn't limited to clothing. It covers EVERY basic need. The principle is universal: any surplus alongside anyone's lack requires sharing.
Reflection Questions
- 1.What do you have TWO of while someone near you has NONE?
- 2.How does the standard being sufficiency (two coats, not wealth) make generosity accessible to everyone?
- 3.What does John the Baptist's answer being MATERIAL (coats, food) teach about the fruit of repentance?
- 4.What 'likewise' — what extension of the coat-sharing principle — applies to your specific surplus?
Devotional
If you have two coats, give one to someone who has none. If you have food, share it. The fruit of repentance isn't mystical or abstract. It's a coat handed to a cold person. It's a meal shared with a hungry person. The evidence of a changed heart is visible in changed material behavior.
The 'he that hath two coats' sets the bar at SUFFICIENCY, not wealth: you don't need to be rich to practice kingdom-generosity. You need TWO of something when someone has NONE. The standard isn't 'give from your abundance after you've secured your comfort.' The standard is: you have two. Someone has zero. The math resolves itself. The action is self-evident.
The 'let him impart' — metadotō (share, give a portion) — means DIVIDING: the generosity isn't giving everything away. It's DIVIDING what you have. You have two coats. You give one. You keep one. The sharing is a HALVING — reducing your surplus to meet someone's deficit. The generosity isn't heroic self-sacrifice. It's obvious math: two minus one equals one for you and one for them. Both are covered.
The 'he that hath meat, let him do likewise' extends to EVERY necessity: the principle isn't coat-specific. It covers food, and by extension, every basic need. The 'likewise' (homoiōs) makes the coat-principle UNIVERSAL: whatever you have TWO of, when someone has NONE — share. The principle adapts to every commodity. The generosity follows the surplus wherever it appears.
What do you have two of — while someone near you has none?
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
He answereth and saith unto them,.... By telling them what they should do; and he does not put them upon ceremonial…
He that hath two coats ... - Or, in other words, aid the poor according to your ability; be benevolent, and you will…
He that hath two coats, etc. - He first teaches the great mass of the people their duty to each other. They were…
John's baptism introducing a new dispensation, it was requisite that we should have a particular account of it. Glorious…
He that hath two coats St Luke alone preserves for us the details in this interesting section. Beyond the single upper…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture