“And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient;”
My Notes
What Does Romans 1:28 Mean?
Paul describes a terrifying spiral: people who chose not to retain God in their knowledge were given over by God to a reprobate mind. The giving over is not passive neglect. It is active divine response — God releasing people to the consequences of their own rejection.
A "reprobate mind" (adokimos nous) means a mind that fails the test — disqualified, unfit, unable to make sound judgments. When you persistently refuse to acknowledge God, your capacity to think clearly degrades.
The list that follows is devastating: unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness, envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity — and more. Paul is describing what happens to a society when God is systematically excluded from its thinking.
"They did not like to retain God in their knowledge" — the original choice was intellectual. They chose to edit God out. The reprobate mind is the consequence — not a punishment imposed from outside but the natural result of removing the foundation of moral reasoning.
Reflection Questions
- 1.What does 'not liking to retain God in knowledge' look like in modern culture?
- 2.How is God 'giving them over' different from God punishing them directly?
- 3.Where have you quietly edited God out of your thinking in specific areas of life?
- 4.How does removing God from your intellectual framework affect your capacity for moral reasoning?
Devotional
They did not like to retain God in their knowledge. The decision was quiet, intellectual, deliberate. Not a dramatic rebellion. A choice to stop thinking about God. To edit him out of the operating system.
God gave them over to a reprobate mind. That is one of the most sobering phrases in Scripture. God did not argue. He did not force. He released them to the consequences of their own choice. You wanted a mind without God? Here it is.
The list that follows reads like a diagnosis of what happens when moral reasoning loses its foundation: every form of wickedness, relational destruction, and social decay. Not because God punished them with these things, but because removing God from your thinking removes the framework that prevented them.
This is not about people who never heard of God. It is about people who knew and chose to forget. The reprobate mind is the end of a process — each dismissal of God making the next one easier, until the capacity for sound moral judgment is gone.
Where are you choosing not to retain God in your knowledge? Where have you quietly edited him out? The mind that removes God from its thinking does not stay neutral. It degrades. Slowly, quietly, and then suddenly.
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
And even as they did not like,.... This accounts for the justness of the divine procedure in leaving them to commit such…
And even as they did not like ... - This was the true source of their crimes. They did not choose to acknowledge God. It…
They did not like to retain God - It would, perhaps, be more literal to translate ουκ εδοκιμασαν, They Did Not Search to…
In this last part of the chapter the apostle applies what he had said particularly to the Gentile world, in which we may…
And even as, &c. In this and the following verses the developements of sin are followed into less monstrous but more…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture