“Yea, all Israel have transgressed thy law, even by departing, that they might not obey thy voice; therefore the curse is poured upon us, and the oath that is written in the law of Moses the servant of God, because we have sinned against him.”
My Notes
What Does Daniel 9:11 Mean?
Daniel is praying one of the most remarkable prayers in Scripture — a prayer of corporate confession during the Babylonian exile. And his confession is total. "All Israel have transgressed thy law, even by departing, that they might not obey thy voice." Not some of Israel. Not the leaders while the people stayed faithful. All. The transgression was universal, and the mechanism was departure — they walked away from obedience. They left.
"Therefore the curse is poured upon us" — Daniel doesn't argue with the punishment. He doesn't claim it's disproportionate. He doesn't suggest mitigating circumstances. The curse was written in the law of Moses — Deuteronomy 28 spells it out in terrifying detail — and Israel walked straight into it. The exile isn't God being cruel. It's God being consistent. He said what would happen, and it happened.
"The oath that is written in the law of Moses the servant of God" — this phrase connects the exile to Sinai, to the covenant, to the terms Israel agreed to. The curse isn't arbitrary. It's covenantal. Israel entered a binding agreement with God, violated its terms, and the consequences clause activated. Daniel isn't discovering new information. He's reading the contract and acknowledging that every clause has been fulfilled.
"Because we have sinned against him" — notice the pronoun. Daniel says "we," not "they." He includes himself in the confession even though he's one of the most righteous men in the Bible. He doesn't stand apart from his people's sin. He stands in it, with it, confessing it as his own. That's the posture of a true intercessor.
Reflection Questions
- 1.How does Daniel's use of 'we' instead of 'they' challenge the way you talk about the failures of your community, your church, or your family?
- 2.Is there an area of your life where you've been arguing with consequences instead of acknowledging that they're just?
- 3.What does it look like to confess sins you didn't personally commit — to stand in solidarity with your people rather than apart from them?
- 4.Daniel's honest confession opened the door to prophetic revelation. Have you experienced a connection between honesty with God and hearing from God?
Devotional
Daniel's prayer is a masterclass in honest confession — and the hardest part might be the word "we." Daniel was taken captive as a teenager. He never worshipped idols. He risked his life to pray three times a day toward Jerusalem. He's arguably the most faithful person in the entire exile. And he says: we have sinned. We transgressed. The curse is upon us.
That "we" is the difference between someone who criticizes their community from the outside and someone who takes responsibility from within. Daniel doesn't say "they got what they deserved." He says "we sinned against Him." He binds himself to his people — to their failures, to their consequences, to their need for mercy. That's not false guilt. It's solidarity.
There's also a bracing honesty in his acknowledgment of the curse. He doesn't spin it. He doesn't soften it. He reads Deuteronomy 28 and says: yes. This is what was promised, and this is what happened. We were told. We agreed. We broke the agreement. The exile makes sense. Sometimes the most faithful thing you can do is stop arguing with consequences and start acknowledging that they're just.
Daniel's prayer leads, in the verses that follow, to one of the most important prophecies in the Bible — the seventy weeks, the coming Messiah. It's as if God was waiting for someone to stop making excuses and start telling the truth. Honest confession opened the door to divine revelation. It usually does.
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
Yea, all Israel have transgressed thy law,.... Even God's professing people, on whom he had bestowed distinguishing…
Yea, all Israel have transgressed ... - Embracing not only the tribe and the kingdom of Judah, but the whole nation. The…
Therefore the curse is poured upon us - It is probable that he alludes here to the punishment of certain criminals by…
We have here Daniel's prayer to God as his God, and the confession which he joined with that prayer: I prayed, and made…
even by departing and have turned aside, as Dan 9:9.
so as not to obey(hearken to) thy voice as Jer 18:10; Jer 42:13…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture