“I am black, but comely, O ye daughters of Jerusalem, as the tents of Kedar, as the curtains of Solomon.”
My Notes
What Does Song of Solomon 1:5 Mean?
The beloved speaks with both honesty and confidence: "I am black, but comely." The word "black" (shechorah — dark-skinned, swarthy, darkened by sun exposure) describes her appearance as affected by outdoor labor (verse 6: "they made me the keeper of the vineyards; mine own vineyard have I not kept"). The darkness is the result of work, not of nature — she's been laboring in the sun while unable to care for her own appearance.
The word "comely" (na'vah — beautiful, lovely, befitting) asserts beauty alongside the darkness: the two coexist. She's not beautiful despite being dark. She's dark AND beautiful. The conjunction "but" in KJV could equally be translated "and" — the Hebrew vav can mean either. She may be saying: I am dark AND I am beautiful. Both are true.
The comparisons — "as the tents of Kedar" (black goat-hair tents of the nomadic Kedarites) and "as the curtains of Solomon" (the most magnificent royal tapestries in the ancient world) — hold both realities: the rough exterior (Kedar) and the royal beauty (Solomon's curtains). The beloved is simultaneously common and magnificent.
Reflection Questions
- 1.How does 'dark AND beautiful' (not 'dark BUT beautiful') change the relationship between your condition and your worth?
- 2.What does the darkness-from-labor (working in others' vineyards) represent about seasons of sacrificial service?
- 3.How do the twin comparisons (tents of Kedar + curtains of Solomon) hold roughness and royalty together?
- 4.What truth about yourself are you hiding because you think it cancels your beauty — and does it?
Devotional
I am dark and I am beautiful. The beloved speaks her identity with both honesty about her condition (weathered by outdoor labor) and confidence in her worth (beautiful despite — or alongside — the darkness). The two truths coexist.
The darkness isn't shame. It's evidence of labor: she's been working in the vineyards, exposed to the sun, unable to maintain the pale complexion that ancient beauty standards preferred. The darkness tells a story of work, of service to others' vineyards while neglecting her own (verse 6). The skin that the daughters of Jerusalem might judge carries the testimony of a life spent producing for others.
The beauty assertion alongside the darkness is the verse's quiet revolution: she doesn't wait for the darkness to fade before claiming beauty. She claims both simultaneously. I am this. AND I am this. The labor-marked exterior and the genuine loveliness exist in the same person, in the same sentence, without one canceling the other.
The twin comparisons — tents of Kedar (dark, rough, nomadic) and curtains of Solomon (royal, magnificent, the most beautiful fabric in the kingdom) — hold the tension visually. The same person is compared to rough goat-hair tents AND to palace tapestries. The exterior suggests one thing. The reality reveals another. The Kedar tent covers a Solomon's curtain.
The allegorical reading (the beloved as the church, the lover as Christ) adds another layer: the church is dark — marked by living in a world that weathers and wears. But comely — genuinely beautiful to the one who sees her as she truly is. The darkness doesn't reduce the beauty in the Lover's eyes. Both are true. Both are held.
What about your appearance, your condition, or your story are you hiding because you think it cancels your beauty?
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
This section is made by the Targumist and other Jewish interpreters to adumbrate the condition of Israel in the…
Here the Shulammite, under the inquisitive glances of the court ladies, who probably desire to see whether they have in…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture