“Of whom is Hymenaeus and Alexander; whom I have delivered unto Satan, that they may learn not to blaspheme.”
My Notes
What Does 1 Timothy 1:20 Mean?
Paul names two people — Hymenaeus and Alexander — whom he has "delivered unto Satan." The delivery isn't abandonment. It's discipline: the purpose is "that they may learn not to blaspheme." The handing-over is educational. The destruction is corrective. Satan is being used as a classroom.
The phrase "delivered unto Satan" (paradidōmi — to hand over, the same word used for Judas' betrayal and for God giving up humanity in Romans 1) means Paul has formally removed these men from the church's protective community and placed them in Satan's jurisdiction. The church is the realm of God's protection. Outside the church is the realm where Satan operates. The delivery puts them where the consequences of their behavior will be felt.
"That they may learn not to blaspheme" is the purpose: the delivery is pedagogical. They haven't been sent to Satan for punishment. They've been sent to learn. The lesson — don't blaspheme — is what the delivery is designed to produce. Satan's domain is the classroom. The suffering experienced there is the curriculum. And the hoped-for outcome is: they stop blaspheming and come back.
Reflection Questions
- 1.Does 'delivered to Satan' (removing church protection) describe a form of discipline you've witnessed — or experienced?
- 2.How does the educational purpose ('that they may learn') change the delivery from abandonment to tough love?
- 3.Is the church's protective covering real enough that its removal would be felt as 'delivery to Satan'?
- 4.Does the restoration-aim (they learn and come back) describe how your community practices the hardest discipline?
Devotional
I delivered them to Satan. So they would learn. Not to destroy them. To educate them.
Paul names names: Hymenaeus and Alexander. Both have blasphemed. Both have been formally handed over to Satan — removed from the church's protective covering and placed in the jurisdiction where Satan operates. The delivery sounds devastating. The purpose is restorative: that they may LEARN not to blaspheme.
"Delivered unto Satan" — paradidōmi — the formal handover. The same word used when Judas betrayed Jesus (handing Him over to the authorities). The same word used when God gave up humanity in Romans 1 (handing them over to the consequences of their choices). Paul takes the same verb and applies it to church discipline: I formally hand these men from God's jurisdiction (the church) to Satan's jurisdiction (the world without the church's protection).
The delivery isn't exile. It's exposure: inside the church, the community's prayers, teaching, and fellowship provide a buffer against Satan's full impact. Outside the church, that buffer is removed. The person delivered to Satan experiences the consequences of operating without community protection. And those consequences — whatever they are — are designed to teach.
"That they may learn" — the purpose is educational. Not terminal. Not punitive for its own sake. The delivery to Satan functions as a classroom: the suffering experienced in Satan's domain produces the knowledge that the protection of God's community was valuable. The person who blasphemed inside the church discovers, outside the church, what the church was shielding them from.
The hoped-for outcome: they stop blaspheming. They learn. They come back. The delivery was never permanent. It was the hardest lesson in the most uncomfortable classroom. And the tuition is whatever Satan's jurisdiction produces in a life that's lost the church's covering.
Some lessons can only be learned outside the protection. And the delivery to Satan is the enrollment form.
Commentary
Trusted original commentary from respected historical Bible scholars and theologians.
Of whom is Hymenaeus and Alexander,.... The former of these is mentioned in Ti2 2:17 and that part of faith he made…
Of whom is Hymeneus and Alexander - Hymeneus is nowhere else mentioned in the New Testament, except in 2Ti 2:17, where…
Of whom is Hymeneus and Alexander - Who had the faith but thrust it away; who had a good conscience through believing,…
Here is the charge he gives to Timothy to proceed in his work with resolution, Ti1 1:18. Observe here, The gospel is a…
Hymeneus and Alexander The name Hymenæus occurs again in 2Ti 2:17, and being uncommon and used in both places of an…
Cross References
Related passages throughout Scripture